About this item:
4.0 out of 5
80.00% of customers are satisfied
5.0 out of 5 stars If this were required reading in our schools, alongside the Constitution, it would be transformative
I realize this is a fantasy but, this book should be required reading in our schools. It won't be--particularly in a state like Florida, where it is now against the law to make people uncomfortable talking or reading about America's original sin. What I appreciated the most was the volume of detail that the author assembled. It seems odd to talk about murder, rape and torture as "engaging" but he found a way to do it. The avalanche of detail puts to rest the calumny about this nightmarish part of our history being exaggerated.I was particularly fascinated to learn the actual views of Horace Greeley, Hamilton Fish, and of course, the dastardly and faithless Carl Schurz. There's a six-part mini-series in the offing, one hopes, that will take us from Schurz's journey from the Rhine to Sleepy Hollow. And although I learned the term "carpetbaggers" in grade school, again it was the sheer volume of names and stories the author provided that made me understand how significant these people were, these purportedly effete Northerners from Ivy League schools who dared to think they could help the South recover.The portrait of Grant that emerges in this book is wonderfully nuanced. I am not one of those who has read biographies of all the presidents, so following the arc of his life was a revelation. I am certainly glad he's been re-evaluated as not one of the worst presidents of all time. Surely we have quite a few others who can wear that crown.Randomly, I also loved learning about the odd role of the Albany, NY jail in the Reconstruction, and the role of the NY Herald, which could always be counted on to say something vituperous, it seems.
5.0 out of 5 stars Very detailed history of the Reconstruction
This book focuses on the Reconstruction period following the Civil War, particularly during the first presidential term of Ulysses S. Grant. It describes the political efforts in the southern states and in Washington to try to give freed slaves a chance to establish productive and dignified lives of their own, while at the same time trying to respond effectively to the Ku Klux Klan and other reactionary people who wanted to undo the result of the Civil War and re-establish some form of slavery. A key tension during this period was between reconstructionism, a proactive federal effort to create a peaceful multi-racial society by protecting and assisting the newly-freed people; and "redemptionism," a passive northern attitude, especially among the business elite that enabled backsliding and forgot past "unpleasantness."Bordewich describes in thorough detail how the Klan gained power, the many violent acts they carried out, and the failures of various efforts to appease them. Grant had initially been reluctant to intervene, not least because the Congress was unwilling to provide resources to do so. But as time went on and the atrocities piled up, Grant gradually increased his efforts. Ultimately the Klan itself was beaten back, but the fearful attitudes of southern conservatives continued unabated, violence continued, and inequality was further baked into the political system. Some lasting progress was made, in the form of new constitutional amendments granting freedom from chattel slavery and the right to vote. But as the north lost interest, southern reactionaries found other ways to institute indentured slavery and white supremacy.Bordewich is not a happy book, and many parts are quite painful to read. It's an important book in that it goes into depth about the motivations and pressures on the leaders and on common people who were embroiled in the conflict. It offers useful insight on why certain attitudes and fears persist, and how systemic racism comes into being and is perpetuated in spite of the efforts of well-meaning people.For those who long for a follow-up book that picks up where this one leaves off, I'd recommend:Joseph, Penial E. The Third Reconstruction: America's Struggle for Racial Justice in the Twenty-First Century. Basic Books, 2022. https://www.Bolo.com/gp/product/B09PL4YT58/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_d_asin_title_o00The second book does a fast-forward to what the author describes as the "second reconstruction," the period from the Brown vs Board decision of 1954 to the 1968 assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.; and the "third reconstruction," from the 2008 election of Barack Obama to the present. In a way, Joseph's shorter book is a reward for persevering through Bordewich. It is much more positive, particularly about the Black Lives Matter Movement. Both books discuss how leaders responded to successes and failures in their early efforts, to try to be more effective going forward. Much has been learned and considerable progress has been made, even if not fast enough for many of us.
5.0 out of 5 stars Interesting Read
Enjoyed the history
5.0 out of 5 stars A must read, and relevant 150 years later
Every American should read this book and appreciate our voting rights in this country. What people endured and fought for remains painfully relevant today, and I am grateful for this excellently written book that clearly recounts the immense violence and political courage to secure rights for all Americans post Civil War. It is also good to see Ulysses S. Grant be rightfully reexamined as a great hero and leader of this nation, instead of the previous depiction of him as a corrupt drunk. Excellent book, excellent writing and analysis. Should be required reading in schools.
5.0 out of 5 stars How we got here…
KKK-sponsored terrorism threatens Reconstruction. This is the bloody history occurring in the wake of the Civil War.
5.0 out of 5 stars Worth the wait and aggravation
I initially gave this book a low rating due to a binding problem that prevented me from reading the whole book. Thanks to the quick work of Bolo, I was able to return the defective product and get a new, unblemished copy of the book. I'm glad I gave the book a second chance, because it proved well worth reading. Sometimes long and pedantic, it is nevertheless a very well-researched and thorough examination of a period of history for which we need more such research. Mr. Bordewich has provided us with a source to rebut neo-"Lost Cause" apologists and book banners.
1.0 out of 5 stars Missing Pages
My copy of the hardcover book was missing 32 pages. I should have heeded the other reviews on this point and inspected my copy before the return window closed. I did not…but if you decide to buy the hardcover edition, I encourage you to inspect it for missing pages (e.g., pp. 233-264).
Publisher’s error
I just received this keenly awaited book only to discover my copy is missing pages 233-65. In their place are pages from the index, which then appear again in their correct place at the end. I expected better from a quality publisher like Alfred A. Knopf.
Visit the Knopf Store
BHD19011
Quantity:
Order today to get by
Free delivery on orders over BHD 20
Product origin: United States
Electrical items shipped from the US are by default considered to be 120v, unless stated otherwise in the product description. Contact Bolo support for voltage information of specific products. A step-up transformer is required to convert from 120v to 240v. All heating electrical items of 120v will be automatically cancelled.
Or share with link
https://bolo.com/